The title pretty much sums up the book. In five chapters, the author discusses five dangerous illusions that beset the United States. They’re the illusions of:
- Literacy — crap like professional wrestling and reality TV and the distractions of celebrity culture in general)
- Love — the popularity of pornography, especially the kind that demeans women
- Wisdom — how colleges have been turned into glorified vocational schools
- Happiness — the “positive psychology” movement that offers false promises and promotes conformity
- America — how the “greatest democracy” on Earth is actually a militaristic empire in the service of corporate capitalism.
He often exaggerates how bad things are, but the book serves as a good corrective to the idea that this is a healthy nation. Some of the negativity derives from the fact that Empire of Illusion was published in 2009 during the financial turmoil of the Great Recession. For example, Hedges casts doubt on the idea that the Obama administration would make any improvement to our health care system, such as making sure that more of us have adequate health insurance.
Even if he overstates some of the problems, he criticisms all have a basis in reality. A brief sample:
Individualism is touted as the core value of American culture, and yet most of us meekly submit, as we are supposed to, to the tyranny of the corporate state…. There is a vast and growing disconnect between what we say we believe and what we do. We are blinded, enchanted and finally enslaved by illusion…..[p. 182].
The more we sever ourselves from a literate, print-based world, a world of complexity and nuance, a world of ideas, for one informed by comforting, reassuring images, fantasies, slogans, celebrities, and a lust for violence, the more we are destined to implode. As the collapse continues and our suffering mounts, we yearn, like World Wrestling Entertainment fans, or those who confuse pornography with love, for the comfort, beauty and reassurance of illusion….And the lonely Cassandras who speak the truth about our misguided imperial wars, the economic meltdown, or the immindent danger of multiple pollution and soaring overpopulation, are drowned out by arenas of excited fans….[pp. 189-190].
I expect Mr. Hedges would offer our demagogic president’s scary political rallies as further confirmation of his thesis.